So, I had the same wallet for years upon years. I think I got my Trove in 2015 or 2016 and used it all the way until I bought a Apple MagSafe wallet last year.
It was great, but falling apart.
When I got the MagSafe one, I knew it was kind of just half of a solution for me. Because the MagSafe wallet is a great when I want to carry one thing. Like going to the store or going out for drinks. Basically any situation where I would not disconnect it to use another MagSafe thingy.
And a while back I ordered another wallet. This will most likely be the thing I use most of the time. After looking at various options I went with a yellow Bellroy Card Sleeve.
It is great. It can fit a bunch of cards, I only have three in mine And it has two pockets for easy access to frequently used stuff. Plus a large pocket in the middle for a bunch of cards. Plus a pull thingy to make it easy to get them out of the center pocket.